Delusional about Katyn text. I think if the historian writes this bullshit vryatli he can be a good

Topic "Notes on the shoulder straps." Reaction to vuluchenne film "Katyn" at the Oscars. Quite predictable. Then, they are "chasing". A vote in the "New York Times" "Katyn" wins when the film will actually receive the "Oscar" of such tales in the Russian press will be much more.
dassie2001 says (tentatively) that the author of article - the clown. He promised to consult with serious historians about the merits and author's reputation. Polish historians, however, already reached a verdict - a clown :)
Author - arms historian say the best in the Russian expert on the history of artillery. But often presents itself as a historian and historian of wars in general. And I must say that it works, for example. "War of Northern Russia", volume is very playful and well like that, but they reek of subjectivism for 100 miles. However, if you compare johannes grГјtzke it to "Northern johannes grГјtzke War ..." with Tarle, the subjectivity is very much right.
Delusional about Katyn text. I think if the historian writes this bullshit vryatli he can be a good specialist ... Works on the history of his arms I do not know, but if not figuring on the basis of an eccentric johannes grГјtzke site ... narod.ru that there sculpts it uniquely idiot.
Historian is a special weapons such historian :), but here Ostap suffered and being suffered long. And on that site only book about Katyn laid out here is probably based on them, and he wrote at the same time pearnul site, but what a book there - still need to understand.
I did not look it, but be sure to look ... I hope somebody to bring DVD. How to look carefully Learn share experiences and then you can apply - see ladies :) So do not worry!
On Friday, February 8 in Grodno the film "Katyn", by the famous Polish director Andrzej Wajda. The show will take place in the framework of the campaign "Free Cinema". Wide screen, good sound. Start: Friday, February 8, 18:00, Grodno, Budennogo 48a-44 (Society of Belarusian Schools).
Immediately after the release of "Katyn" on Polish screens WPROST said rather harsh article. Who have the opportunity - I advise to read. (Somewhere even that room I zavalyavsya) Walked on how Wajda movie divides Poles on unruly, sincere patriots (white) and Galimov chmoshnikov-conformists - in the longer term, those who gave the Communists Katyn and went to serve them (black). So at some point the author wonders - and what he was and what kind of movies filmed in the Soviet time Andrzej Wajda, son buried in Katyn officer.
You know, I'm in school in grade 9 was very indignant when he heard Russian literature lesson - Pushkin was typical of a constant state of love - in the sense of Pushkin donzhunski list, etc. I mean if a neighbor Uncle Vasya if it is in a constant state of love called him quite differently. And tell me such "irregularities" This is true or not? So it is with Wajda.
Andrew, can be "you". Sorry you did not recognize me. :)) Do not quite understand the analogy that you want to spend - explanatory. PS. Personally I am against Wajda nothing. But surprised johannes grГјtzke sharp critic position. I have not spoken of the opinion that it was not brought up the topic Wajda Katyn in cinematography, and climbed on the topic. So to say fuck her for its own sake. While writing this Vprost, not some yellow piece of paper.
Wajda situation differs from the situation with Uncle Fyodor that to justify their compromise has Wajda films ... And my Uncle Fyodor? something that he and his family was well ... Example of pahodma johannes grГјtzke musicians in the administration - if one of the opposition would go to Proleskovsky and came out with the news of such concessions are declared rockers johannes grГјtzke (do not meddle in politics and flags do not wave) with him to not a stone was left - a number of rockers had skiff defenders. You can complain that it's not fair - but it's johannes grГјtzke a fact. In his defense, Wolski has its songs ... So Pushkin - in a state of permanent love, and Uncle Fyodor bl ... ext. Well as interesting as I know you can not? On a picture? Here is Myaleshka in amrykanskaga reyzhera disguise just asked if I knew him ... :)
Put the name of exchange johannes grГјtzke on the reader and you will be happy :))). As for Wajda and Volsky - not here Bardi gras. Wolski did not start his career with happy songs about the Soviet future, unlike the first Wajda films ... And then a little about it. Simply (in the author's opinion Vprost) depicted in Katyn in dark colors image opportunists very similar to Vaida very young.
Perhaps johannes grГјtzke Vprost rights and that this ... And Wolski played at various Komsomol activities, not the same? If we continue to look, you can still find ... But it is not my goal. Can we once, as well as in Poland now, will young historians and journalists to dig into biographies meters and was surprised to find a variety of tricky johannes grГјtzke points ... So what? Wajda films and songs Volsky it worse or better will not. May change personality assessment ... If Wajda she almost has not changed after the discovery GB archives that my already